INTERNET ENGINEERING STEERING GROUP (IESG) December 17, 1998 Reported by: Marcia Beaulieu ATTENDEES --------- Alvestrand, Harald / Maxware Bradner, Scott / Harvard Coltun, Rob / Fore Systems Faltstrom, Patrik / Swipnet Leech, Marcus / Nortel Marine, April / Raytheon STX Moore, Keith / U of Tennessee Narten, Thomas / IBM Paxson, Vern / Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory Perkins, Charlie / Sun (IAB Liaison) Reynolds, Joyce K. / ISI (IANA Liaison) Schiller, Jeff / MIT Wijnen, Bert / IBM Regrets ------- Baker, Fred / Cisco Systems Burgan, Jeff / @home Carpenter, Brian / IBM (IAB Liaison) Coya, Steve / CNRI Minutes ------- 1. The minutes of the November 19 Teleconference were approved as corrected. Steve to post at the shadow sites. 2. The IESG did not approve Megaco as a Working group as text was needed to address security. Scott to provide and Steve to send to IESG. 3. The proposal for the Instant Messaging and Presence Protocol (impp) has been withdrawn from IESG consideration. When ready, will be resubmitted. 4. The IESG approved publication of Routing Protocol Performance Issues and Evaluation considerations as an Informational RFC. Steve to send announcement. 5. The IESG approved publication of Users' Security Handbook as an Informational RFC. Steve to send announcement. 7. Keith noted a number of problems with NFS Version 4 Requirements . This document will require an update. Keith will contact the authors. 8. Keith Moore to re-review Neda's Efficient Mail Submission and Delivery (EMSD)Protocol Specification Version 1.3 and provide input to the RFC Editor. 9. The IESG believes that NFS Version 2 and Version 3 Security Issues and the NFS Protocol's Use of RPCSEC_GSS and Kerberos V5 should be considered as a standards track document, not Informational (as originally submitted. Vern to contact author and Steve to convey to RFC Editor. 10. The IESG wants to wait for the next version of Building Directories from DNS: Experiences from WWWSeeker . Once version -03 announced, Steve to inform RFC Editor the IESG has no problem with publication. 11. The IESG has no problem with the publication of Hyper Text Caching Protocol (HTCP/0.0) as an Experimental Protocol, but with an explicit note: This is an experimental protocol, one of several proposals to perform this function. Further, Vern to provide comments to author - may result in a revised document. Steve to wait for update from Vern (i.e. no problem with publication or another version coming. 12. The IESG has no problem with the publication of PPP Over Ethernet (PPPOE) as an Informational RFC. Steve to notify RFC Editor. 13. The IESG had no problem with the publication of MIME Types for Use with the ISO ILL Protocol as an Informational RFC. Steve to notify RFC Editor. 14. The IESG felt that Anti-UBE and Anti-UCE Keywords in SMTP Banners should not be published as an Informational RFC. Patrik to convey to author, Steve to notify RFC Editor. 15. The IESG tentatively approved The Network Access Identifier as a Proposed Standard. If no issues are raised by December 23, Steve to send announcement. 16. Rob Coltun raised the topic of a Routing Co-AD, an additional slot for the NomComm to fill. The IESG agreed to Rob's suggestion, and Fred is to send a note to the NomComm.